All-Time African Squad
Goalkeeper
|
Defender
|
Midfielder
|
Forward
|
Thomas
N'Kono (Cameroon)
Bruce
Grobbelar (Zimbabwe)
|
Patrice
Evra (Senegal)
David Alaba (Nigeria)
Marcel
Desailly (Ghana)
Vicent Kompany (Congo)
Basile Boli (Ivory Coast)
Jerome Boateng (Ghana) Alphonso Davies (Liberia)
|
Patrice Viera (Senegal)
Jean
Tigana (Mali)
Mario
Coluna (Mozambique) Zinedine Zidane (Algeria)
Larbi
Benbarek (Morocco)
Abedi
Pele (Ghana) Riyad Mahrez (Algeria) Sadio Mane (Mali)
|
George
Weah (Liberia)
Samuel
Eto'o (Cameroon)
Eusebio
(Mozambique)
Mohammed Salah
(Egypt)
Kylian Mbappe
(Cameroon) Didier Drogba (Ivory Coast)
|
Manager : Mahmoud El-Gohary (Egypt)
Formation XI (4-3-1-2)
Explanation of Formation
The team strategy is a central
defensive condense without wings. N’Kono is a first choice keeper. Desailly would direct the regularity of the defensive line. Boli is a
main pillar of defenders as a stopper alongside Desailly. Alaba played as right-back. Evra as a
wing-back would run a long distance across functional line from defense to the
wing area. Vieira is a main destroyer of the team. Zidane is a partnership of central midfielders. Mane and Salah are in the left and right flank support scoring from wing-forward area, Weah and Eusebio
would technically and dynamically run from deep-lying forward area to make
scores.
Statistics By Nations
Cameroon : 3
Mozambique : 2
Ghana : 3
Senegal : 2
Ivory Coast : 2
Liberia : 2
Mali : 2
Algeria : 1
Nigeria : 1
Egypt : 1
Zimbabwe : 1
Mali : 1
Positional Ranking
Eras Greatest African Footballers
African Footballer of The Year
The Greatest African Footballers of All-Time
Federic Kanoute I think should be higher. He should at least be better than Muntari. You have also missed Jose Aguas, who would obviously be near the top.
ReplyDeleteIn this scope of selection, only African-born and African-blood player would be allowed. Jose Aguas was a Portuguese blood who born in Africa because their parent moved to work there. I’m quite agree for your suggestion on Kanoute.
DeleteBlood should not be a consideration in any rankings. He grew up and lived in Angola until he was 20. He had more connection to Africa than Dessailly. I really do not think "blood" is an imprtant consdieraton.
DeleteI consider blood (race) is more identifying than period of living (nationality) for African nation as its identity is very obvious. (USA would be different result as it includes many race around the World)
DeleteThe players born in Africa have been selected in all-time squad of those nations they played. This list is just exceptional case to conclude all identifying African.
If you don't think France includes many race around the world, you never get there. By the way, I don't get the big difference between Evra and Zidane. Both french from african parents, the only difference is Evra arrived at 1yo. I don't think these few monthes spent in Africa make a difference.
DeleteSo, I'm a bit disappointed about your list because instead of those european players, we should read Pierre Kalala, Rashidi Yekini, Hossam Hassan, Godfrey Chitalu, Paul Moukila, Badou Zaki, Lucas Radebe, ...
Evra born in Senegal but Zidane born in France. I already have major africa all-time XI without European player but I want to make this one different.
DeleteI think Eto'o should be player of the year in 2011 instead of Toure. He had a very good season at Inter. I also find it unlikely that Evra was above Toure for 2013. Evra was poor recent seasons. Evan Benatia would probably be ahead. And if you add a 2014 best player, it would obviously be Yaya Toure. My 2nd for 2014 would be Benatia.
ReplyDeleteThey’re considered equally in domestic competition. Eto’o is clearly better in international club. African Cup of nation was not held in this year so the NT criteria would be lower. I’m OK to replace Toure by Eto’o.
DeleteProbably I’m too impressive on him in 2012 – 2013 season. Note that he is also rated highly by media but Toure must be more impact to the team so it could be reasonable.
What about Japhet N'Doram?
ReplyDeleteWhat about Mehdi Benatia?
ReplyDeleteWhat about Hatem Trabelsi?
ReplyDeleteMahamadou Diarra should be in your top 50. I would say he was definitely greater than Muntari and Benni Mcarthy
ReplyDeleteRui Jordão should be ranked. He is better than Mccarthy.
ReplyDeleteGreat suggestion. Rui Jordao was not only born in Africa but he also has African blood. I also add Paul Bonga Bonga who was selected in FIFA XI once in the list and also add a forgotten Tshimen Bwanga. So I name Haruna Ilreika, Kanoute and B.McCarthy out. Kanoute is debatable but I think he had only twice great domestic seasons.
DeleteI would definitely rank Mahmadou Diarra and Kanoute ahead of Muntari and Diouf. Diouf is overrated because of the World Cup
ReplyDeleteI would definitely rank Mahmadou Diarra and Kanoute ahead of Muntari and Diouf. Diouf is overrated because of the World Cup
ReplyDeleteI saw Muntari is more versatile than Diarra in supporting attacking game. Diarra was selected in Ligue 1 best XI only once, I know Essien was there so it is too difficult for Diarra but at least he should have been selected in 2004 but not.
DeleteI'd compare Diouf in similar case of Roger Milla. They're not consistent in club level but in their peak, it is considered as a major highlight in history of African football.
Adebayor higher than kanu??
ReplyDeleteKanu was twice african player of the year and was in the top 10 fifa world player of the year 96.
Kanu is by far a superior technical and creative player but it was several times useless and ineffective due to his bad physical ability and condition although his peak in a few matches is considered as a better one, it is too short. His great skills also did not fulfill his performance as a position of forward, too slow and below average shooting skill.
DeleteI SUGGEST INCLUSION OF CHAD Japhet N'Doram BEST PLAYER EVER.
ReplyDeleteI SUGGEST INCLUSION OF M’BOMMA (CAMEROON)
ReplyDeleteI think his career is too inconsistent.
Deletesorry u dont know nothing about african football
ReplyDeletedelete all the names that had been playing for europe countries national teams
and read something about egyptian players kings of africa 7 times
I think you should specify which Egyptian player should be included and which one should be named off and give the reason.
DeleteWhat about Mohammed Abutrika 2008 ?
ReplyDeleteWhat about Godfrey Chitalu in the list and 1978 ?
What about Mustapha Dahleb in the list "Best player in PSG club history" ?
What about Saleh Selim in the list ?
What about Lakhdar Belloumi 1981 , 1982 ?
What about Rachid Makhloufi 1967?
What about Nasr El-Din Abbas "Jaxa" 1970?
What about Ali Abugreisha 1969?
What about Moustafa Reyadh 1964 "best striker in the world 1964" ?
Most of them are named in all-time squad of North American and Subsaharan Africa but I have omitted Godfrey Chitalu, Nasr El-Din Abbas and Moustafa Reyadh who seems should have been qualified. Let me spend some time to include their names in in all-time squad of North American and Subsaharan Africa.
DeleteOK ... thank you
DeleteWhere is zinedine zidane ???
ReplyDeleteHer is african( algeria )
He is named in European hall of fame as he played only for France and also born France. So he is not eligible to be chosen for another continent.
DeleteEusebio play for Portugal.
DeletePatrice Evra play for France.
Mario coluna play for Portugal.
Marcel Desailly play for France
Patrice Vieira play for France
Claude makelele play for France
but they are in this list.
Here has a different criteria to International Legendary Museum. I want to include all African-born and blood (Lose-African). It is another sight of African football history.
DeleteWhere is EMANUEL KUNDÉ ?
ReplyDeleteThis is the most balanced team by continent
ReplyDeleteIf Zidane is not in the list I think you should remove Benzema and M'Bappe both born in France if I am not mistaken.
ReplyDeleteIf you want to include all African-born and blood (Lose-African) but you don't include Zidane you must also remove Pogba, Benzema, M'Bappe... born in france. And double check your top 50 list.
ReplyDeleteWhat ? Umtiti above Alaba ? How is it possible?
ReplyDeleteOK, Revised.
DeleteI am from Portugal and we had some of the Best players from the african colonias
ReplyDeleteWhat about Eboué ?
ReplyDeleteVieira is Patrick Vieira not Patrice Vieira.
ReplyDelete"Patrick" not "Patrice"
Benni McCarthy and Lucas Radebe don't deserve to be here
ReplyDeleteI understand that Olisadebe has been nominated for Ballon d'Or, but I think his career doesn't allow him to be above the other strikers in this list. Osimhen was nominated as well, and he was MVP of Serie A. All other strikers have had a better career than Olisadebe, too.
ReplyDelete